SoftwareOperationsAutomation
Buy, connect or build: how to choose business software
Off-the-shelf, integrated or custom. Three honest options, and the questions that tell you which one your business needs.

The short version
Most small businesses don't have a software problem. They have five tools that don't talk to each other, and one spreadsheet holding it all together. Before you buy another product or commission something custom, work out which of three options you actually need: buy, connect or build. Usually in that order.
Option 1: buy
Off-the-shelf software is right when your process is ordinary. Accounting, payroll, email, bookings and basic customer records work much the same way in every business, and someone else has already built them well.
It suits you when the product does the job without you bending the way you work.
The limits: you fit its way of working, you pay per user for as long as you use it, and it rarely covers the part of your business that is unusual.
Option 2: connect
Often the tools are fine. The problem is the gaps between them: the customer typed into three systems, the report stitched together from four exports.
Connecting the tools you already have keeps the software your team knows and removes the retyping.
It suits you when each tool does its own job well, and the pain is double entry and numbers that don't match.
The limits: connections need looking after. When one product changes, the link has to keep up, so make sure something tells you when a connection breaks.
Option 3: build
Custom software makes sense when the process is what makes you different, no product fits it, and the workaround costs more than the build.
It suits you when a critical job runs on a spreadsheet only one person understands, or you want to give customers something no competitor has.
The limits: it costs more up front, and someone has to look after it. Start with the smallest version that is useful, put it in front of real users early, and make sure you own the code.
Five questions that decide it
- Is this process special to us, or the same as everyone's? Ordinary means buy. Special means connect or build.
- Where do we type the same thing twice? That is where connecting pays first.
- Which spreadsheet would hurt most if it broke, or if its owner left? That is the first candidate for a proper system.
- What would we do with the hours we'd save? If there's no answer, the project can wait.
- Who will look after it in a year? Every option needs an owner.
Common mistakes
- Replacing everything at once with one big system, and stopping the business to do it.
- Buying for the feature list instead of the job your team does every day.
- Building custom for something an existing product already does well.
- Forgetting the data. Check who owns it, and whether you can get it out again.
Where to go next
If the answer is connect, see Software Integration. If it's build, see Custom Software. And if you're not sure which it is, tell us what's going on and we'll give you a straight answer, including when the right move is to buy something off the shelf.